CUSTOM RUGS CUSTOM RUGS
Clash of the Coordinators: Three Top Designers Debate the Biggest Rug Rules to Break
10 Aug 2025
Guide to Choosing and Styling

For decades, the world of interior design has been governed by a set of sacred "rug rules." You know the ones: the rug must be big enough for all the furniture's front legs, it should have a pattern that complements the room, and never, ever, should you place a rug on top of carpet. These rules were created to provide a foolproof guide to a cohesive home. But in a world that craves personality over perfection, are these rules still relevant?

We brought together three top (and fiercely opinionated) interior designers to find out. Elena Vance, the queen of serene minimalism; Julian Croft, the master of eclectic maximalism; and Anya Sharma, the artistic rule-breaker, are here to debate the biggest rug rules they love to break, proving that sometimes, the most beautiful rooms are the ones that dare to be different.

 

Featured Image

Rule #1: "A Rug Must Be the Statement Piece"

The Traditional Rule: A rug, especially one of the large area rugs in a living room, should be a major focal point with a significant color or pattern.

Elena Vance (The Minimalist) Says: BREAK IT. "I find this rule incredibly limiting. A room doesn't need to shout to be beautiful. I believe the most sophisticated spaces are built on texture, not just pattern. A large, neutral rug in a solid color but with a rich, high-quality texture—like a hand-knotted wool or a chunky jute—can be far more impactful than a busy pattern. It creates a calm, serene foundation that allows the architecture of the room and the quality of the furniture to speak for themselves. It’s about creating a feeling of quiet luxury, and a neutral, textural rug is the perfect starting point."

Rule #2: "Only One Rug Per Room"

The Traditional Rule: Using more than one rug in a single space will make it look cluttered and chaotic.

Julian Croft (The Maximalist) Says: BREAK IT. "This is my favorite rule to break! The idea that you can only have one rug is so sterile. Layering rugs is the secret to creating a room that feels rich, collected, and full of personality. It's a technique that adds incredible depth and texture. I love to start with a large, neutral base, like a simple jute or sisal rug, and then layer a smaller, more vibrant vintage or patterned rug on top at an angle. It's a fantastic way to define a smaller zone within a larger room, like a reading nook. It tells a story; it says that this home has been curated over time. It’s a sign of a confident and well-traveled soul."

Rule #3: "The Rug Must Fit the Furniture Perfectly"

The Traditional Rule: The rug must be large enough to fit under at least the front legs of all the main furniture pieces. A standard living room requires one of the area rugs 8x10 or larger.

Anya Sharma (The Artistic Rule-Breaker) Says: BREAK IT. "This is the rule I hear repeated most often, and it's the one that stifles the most creativity. While a large rug is a safe choice, it's not the only choice. Why not use a smaller, more artful rug as a centerpiece, like a piece of art for the floor? I love using unconventional shapes in unexpected ways. One of my favorite moves is to use one of the beautiful round area rugs off-center in a room with very linear furniture. The curve breaks up all the hard angles and creates a wonderful sense of flow and energy. Or, place a smaller, exquisitely patterned vintage rug next to a chair, not under it. It becomes a 'moment,' a small, intentional island of beauty. It’s about using the rug to create interest and personality, not just to follow a diagram in a textbook."

Conclusion: The Only Rule is Your Rule

The verdict is in: the old rules are made to be broken. While traditional guidelines can be a helpful starting point, our designers agree that the best rooms are the ones that reflect the personality of the people who live in them. So, whether you embrace the calm of a textural neutral, the richness of layered patterns, or the playful energy of an unexpectedly placed rug, the most important rule is to choose what you love. Your home is your story—tell it your way, from the floor up.